This isn't nearly as expensive as the other crazy special editions on this list, but this certainly became one of the most controversial. Announced back in January 2013, a figurine included in Dead Island Riptide was a bloody female torso in an American flag bikini. No full body with a head, arms, or legs -- just the torso.
What Deep Silver probably attempted to be a conversation starter instead ignited the argument flames of female over-sexualization in video games. They apologized to those that were offended, but the product was still released.
Image credit: NAG Online