Did Bungie Misrepresent Destiny?

Could one make the argument that Bungie misrepresented Destiny? Did the marketing indicate a different kind of game?

Most of the major critics have weighed in by now, and the Destiny review scores are disappointing: A 6 from GameSpot and Polygon, a 7.8 from IGN, 3 out of 5s from Giant Bomb and The Escapist, etc. We here at GameSkinny gave Destiny an 8 out of 10.

Many gamers also seem disappointed in the final product, as they're unimpressed with the core gameplay - which many deem to be overly repetitive and lacking in variety - and don't believe their expectations were met.

Then again, you've got a very large and vocal group of fans who love the game. The two groups in question are at definite odds; one really seems to despise the other. One could argue that those who are having fun, who are more than satisfied with the result, weren't misled by Bungie and Activision's marketing, while the critics held Destiny to that standard.

Perhaps the biggest complaint revolves around the single-player action

There are two clear similarities among critics who are obviously disappointed with the game: First, the aforementioned repetition and lack of diversity in the overall gameplay, and second, the complete letdown of a storyline. Now, this is perhaps where we could say the developers purposely misrepresented the game. When the project was first revealed, Bungie went out of their way to tell anyone who would listen that it's not just about the multiplayer. They said several times there would be a robust, engaging story and if one desired, one could play the entire game solo.

The latter point isn't entirely untrue. You can certainly go through the game by yourself and never join up with other players. However, I think we all know that such a game isn't really designed for that, and you'll get the most out of it by participating in multiplayer. Furthermore, as the game was designed with multiplayer at its core - a fact Bungie seemed to want to avoid - that story was destined to fall well shy.

I'm not saying Bungie or Activision ever flat-out lied. I'm just saying they tried to say Destiny would be more of an all-encompassing jack-of-all-trades that would satisfy every type of gamer. And that isn't true.

Hype can have an impact on both gamers AND developers

It's possible that Bungie was only trying to put out the fires. It was an all-too-common question after the initial unveiling: Would it actually have a story? Could you really play it by yourself and still enjoy a full experience? In answering such questions, Bungie had no choice but to adopt a more promotional tone, as opposed to a more candid one. At least, I assume they had no choice. However, had they just come clean and said, "yes, this game is designed with multiplayer entertainment in mind, and that will be the focal point, as opposed to a story-driven narrative," I think review scores would've been higher, and this controversy wouldn't exist.

At its core, Destiny is a multiplayer shooter. That's really what it is. And you know, it's pretty darn good for what it is. Sure, there's some repetition and lack of variety but that's sort of par for the course for the genre. I mean, it's not like there has been a heck of a lot of innovation in the Call of Duty multiplayer component and everyone loved it, time and time again. I really think Bungie gave shooter fans precisely what they wanted. All I'm suggesting is that they tried to prove to other gamers that Destiny would appeal to them.

That's where they lost a lot of gamers, I think.

Featured Columnist

A gaming journalism veteran of 14 years, a confirmed gamer for over 30 years, and a lover of fine literature and ridiculously sweet desserts.

Published Sep. 20th 2014
  • MunKy_3539
    @Si_W

    Isn't Battlefield the same as COD? Isn't NHL hockey the same as John Madden footie? Isn't Shadows of Mordor just the same as Assassins Creed.

    No...
  • Scout_9459
    A story should be seamless from the first game to the sequel, trying to sell a story through the use of DLC so it make the DLC mandatory to purchase in order to understand what is happening in a story is an unethical business plan base on greed.
  • Konfess.
    Return on Investment. Someone was asked to determine the ROI of a single player storyline (SPSL). Their assessment, was little or none. So little or none was invested in the SPSL. I’m only speculating here, I have no inside knowledge on the issues. They could have invested time in money on a SL, and found out too late that the same idea had been pitched and was now owned else where.

    Another developer famous for their SL met unhappy gamers when they tried to mix SL with multiplayer gaming.
  • Rothalack
    Master O' Bugs
    The whole point is that the story is supposed to last the next ten years. That is what they are aiming for, from what I've seen the story thus far is just set up, back drop, to give a place for the ten year story to unfold.
  • Dirk_7586
    They advertized Destiny as a single player and multiplayer experience. The single player experience is a lot like when Modern Warfare came out. I think it had 4-8 hours of gameplay and that was it. That was forgiven by many because of the fact that Call of Duty had finally moved into the present and it was a very good story. Since then Call of Duty has been basically crap for single player experiences. The same can be said for Destiny with a crap story, crap RPG elements, and crap customization/distinctiveness for the player that you can't even change until well into to the game. On top of that the story might last you 8-10 hours or so. So I pay $60 (USD) for 8-10 hours of gameplay when I can spend the same amount on other games and obtain 30+ hours out of the gameplay. Destiny is not a very good deal.
  • Si_W
    Isn't it just the same kind of thing as Defiance?
  • Venisia Gonzalez
    Featured Columnist
    You have very good points stated and none that I'd disagree on. I, too, thought there'd be a bit more to the single-player aspect. Overall it's a fantastic shooter that I enjoy much better than that of Call of Duty.

Cached - article_comments_article_16610
Related
More Destiny Content