According to a new study, gamers who believe a game has adaptive AI are more likely to rate it as challenging or immersive.

New study shows placebo effect can change gamers’ perceptions of game difficulty and immersion

According to a new study, gamers who believe a game has adaptive AI are more likely to rate it as challenging or immersive.

It isn’t a white sugar pill, but it might be just as potent.

Recommended Videos

Two researchers at the University of York have found that gamers report different gaming experiences when told the game they’re playing has “extra” gameplay features. This occurs even when the game they’re playing has the exact same features.

For their experiment, Paul Cairns and a colleague had a group of participants play two rounds of Don’t Starve, the rogue/surivival adventure game by Klei Entertainment.

Participants were told that the first round of gameplay would feature “randomly generated” map features, including survival items and monsters. The second would instead have an “adaptive AI”, and adjust the gameplay based on the player’s actions and skill level (note: Don’t Starve does have randomly-generated maps, but does not actually feature an artificial intelligence system).

After both rounds, participants were more likely to rate what they believed to be the AI version of the game as more challenging. Other participants rated the AI version as easier, and more helpful in how it dispensed items, and as a more “immersive” experience.

What’s most interesting is that while participants rated the AI version as both less or more challenging than the regular version, no participant said that the versions were of equal difficulty. Expectations changed participants’ views of the game in every instance.

Cairns states that this “changing of perceptions” about game features shows that the placebo effect, often seen in medical and drug research, applies to gaming as well.

So game devs take note: player expectations can be just as important as game features. But please don’t start writing a long list of lies on the back of the box.


GameSkinny is supported by our audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn a small affiliate commission. Learn more
related content
Read Article Skyrim Players Still Want Sexy Armor for Male Characters
Skyrim cover after of an armored male character
Read Article Assassin’s Creed Shadows Ignites Ghost of Tsushima Reddit Debate
Split image of Assassin's Creed Shadows Yasuke and Naoe and Jin Sakai from Ghost of Tsuhima
Read Article Sims 4 Roadmap Teases More Romance With New Content
Sims 4 season of love roadmap, new date spots, kits, expansion, and more
Read Article Little Kitty, Big City Assures Players They Can’t Hurt the Cat
Kitty safely checks out a sunny nap spot inside a satellite dish in Little Kitty Big City
Read Article Helldivers 2 Director Teases New Cape After Review Bombing
helldivers 2 player squad of four
Related Content
Read Article Skyrim Players Still Want Sexy Armor for Male Characters
Skyrim cover after of an armored male character
Read Article Assassin’s Creed Shadows Ignites Ghost of Tsushima Reddit Debate
Split image of Assassin's Creed Shadows Yasuke and Naoe and Jin Sakai from Ghost of Tsuhima
Read Article Sims 4 Roadmap Teases More Romance With New Content
Sims 4 season of love roadmap, new date spots, kits, expansion, and more
Read Article Little Kitty, Big City Assures Players They Can’t Hurt the Cat
Kitty safely checks out a sunny nap spot inside a satellite dish in Little Kitty Big City
Read Article Helldivers 2 Director Teases New Cape After Review Bombing
helldivers 2 player squad of four
Author
Michael Falero
GameSkinny Senior Intern. Writer, Gamer, British TV nerd. Looking out for that big blue box.