Horror games that are anything but scary are the absolute best. Much like their film counterparts, when a jump scare doesn't work, all it ends up doing is making its audience laugh at the sheer stupidity of it all. In comes Amy, a "horror" game so poorly received it was forgotten about the moment it released.
What makes Amy such a perfect of horror done wrong is...well everything. It's a giant escort mission surrounding you guiding a child away from cartoonish monsters, and some of the worst combat mechanics seen in years. Just remember folks, THIS was released and is still available to download to this day, while Silent Hills was scrapped almost as fast as it was announced.