5 Reasons Why Pocket Trains is Better Than Pocket Planes

Some say Pocket Trains is the same game as Pocket Planes. Lets take a look at 5 critical improvements and why Trains will do better than Planes.

Let me start by saying I love NimbleBit games and the studio as a whole. I, like many of you, was hooked when I discovered Tiny Tower. I love the pixel art, the bitizen characters and the little attentions to detail in their games like the Bitbook (mock in-game Facebook). Not only are their games good but it seems like they are the underdogs that everyone is rooting for, and I mean "underdog" in the best way possible - they don't have the capital or resources that their competition has. It's hard not to respect them when they send notes like this to studios who copy their games.

Then there was Pocket Planes. I enjoyed Pocket Planes, but not for very long. I played for less than a month and didn't monetize. I felt the game fell short in a few different aspects. Some complain the gameplay is a little repetitive but that can be said for most games. What's not repetitive about Candy Crush or Clash of Clans? However, the lack of missions and progression got to me. I also ended up discovering a killer strategy. Invest in the larger planes (level 3) and close all airports except your major (level 3) airports. The strategy wasn't dependent on how many airports/routes you had, but relied on sending better planes on longer routes. This seemed more like an exploit rather than a compelling strategy.

When Pocket Trains came out several people around me were initially underwhelmed saying things like "this is just another Pocket Planes." I had to remind them that many games are clones of another, or get inspiration from another game. This isn't a bad thing so long as they improve on the former or inspirational game. After playing Pocket Trains for a while now I think there are 5 critical things that NimbleBit improved to make the game more compelling and I'm sure some of these could be applied to other games out there.

1. Improved Strategy

NimbleBit improved on this in several ways so we'll tackle them one at a time.

  • Pocket Trains encourages expansion. Like I mentioned above, there's a point in Pocket Planes where it doesn't make sense to continue to operate smaller planes and airports so your network shrinks. However, in Pocket Trains you need to keep those previous routes open in order to keep expanding. This helps with the player's sense of progression since their empire is never shrinking.
  • Planning routes is more simplistic. In Pocket Planes it costs money to fly somewhere. This might be more accurate in the real world, but it makes the planning process longer. In the end, I only care about the profit margin from each thing I'm transporting. I do enjoy more expansive/complex strategy games, but this game is on mobile so if you can make it easier to play then it's usually best to do so. 
  • It's all about routes, not who has the best train type. In Pocket Trains each train type has a different set of stats. Some are very fast but don't hold much fuel, and others might have a larger towing capacity but are very slow. There are routes that work better for certain train types and it's up to the player to figure that out. On the surface, players won't recognize this but it's these layers of complexity over a simple set of actions that makes Pocket Trains a much better game. 

Building a network and using the right trains for proper routes is crucial.

2. Can't Buy Specific Trains

In Pocket Planes players can purchase plane parts in order to "build" new planes at a discount, but there's also the option to just buy the plane already built. Having the option to buy the planes instantly devalued them to me. There's no scarcity or nothing special about those planes if you don't need to work for them.

You can buy planes parts...

...or skip it and just purchase planes.

I believe NimbleBit realized this and that's why you can't purchase pre-built trains in Pocket Trains. Players need to collect crates and use "bux" (premium currency) to open them. This makes even paying players work for special train types and it also helps drain player's premium currency, but NimbleBit is also generous with the premium currency so they're not being greedy about it.

I need more special crates to finish these trains! Perhaps I should buy some. :)

3. More Currency Types

Like in previous NimbleBit games there are coins and bux for the standard and premium currencies. However, NimbleBit also added "crates" and "special crate" IAP options. Players come by regular crates pretty often, but special crates are rare and require a large amount of coins to purchase. This is a great accompanying IAP option to bux because bux are required in order to open crates. If I spend $5 on 50 special crates then I'll likely also need some bux to help open that many crates. Adding complementary IAP options like this will greatly increase your odds to persuade players into repeat purchasers.

I bought some special crates...

And needed some bux to open all those crates.

4. Delay with Refueling

In Pocket Planes, when a plane lands from a flight it's immediately ready for the next flight. I also played Pocket Planes religiously for 2 weeks straight, uninstalled, and then never played again. It's not a necessity to have delay in all F2P games, but I really encourage it for games that can be repetitive or shallow to break up sessions lengths to keep player's interest for longer periods of time.

In Pocket Trains, the trains have a certain amount of fuel that they can hold. After traveling, fuel regenerates at a rate of 1 fuel unit every 10 seconds. Players typically wait less than 20 minutes to refuel but this break helps them get away from repetitive tasks, or helps persuade them to monetize if they're in a pinch.

5. Daily Events

In Pocket Planes players could join a team (or flight crew) and participate in events that lasted a few days with other players. The concept sounds great on paper, but there were a few flaws.

  • There's no way to communicate with your flight crew in game.
  • There's no limit to how many players could be in a flight crews so just join a really large flight crew and you'll win. 
  • Events that last more than 1 day on mobile are extremely long. 

I liked the concept of a team event because it was turning a single player game into a multiplayer game, but I don't think it worked out as well as one might have hoped during the designing process.

NimbleBit fixed these event issues in Pocket Trains. They have daily events to encourage players to come back every day to participate and the events are completed on an individual basis versus a team event. This also complements the delay with refueling because players might spend bux to refuel their train or fast travel to a location in order to finish an event if they're close.

Let the Numbers Speak 

It's great to hear someone's opinion on why something is a better game or product, but as a reader I also want to see some validating points or data to backup claims. Here's the top grossing chart data the first couple weeks Pocket Planes was out.

As you can see the game hit its peak on the 5th day and then began to decline. Typically in a freemium game you want your game to level out and maintain. However, Pocket Planes never climbed back up to the position that it was at and was/is on a constant decline except when updates are released. Let's take a look at the Pocket Trains charts.

Now this is what I like to see in a F2P title. It quickly rose into the top 100 grossing and is staying there. Even though it didn't peak as high as Pocket Planes, I'm confident that Pocket Trains will make more in the end. Why didn't it peak as high as Pocket Planes? I don't know for certain, but I believe it's because of the similar style of game so some players aren't downloading, playing, or paying. As for me, I monetized (twice) in Pocket Trains when I never did in Pocket Planes. I hope Pocket Trains can maintain its position, but only time will tell.

If you'd like help designing or monetizing your games feel free to contact me or hit me on Twitter!

Featured Contributor

Ben is a producer/designer who has collaborated on hundreds of titles on mobile, console, PC/Mac and social platforms. The titles have been from kids’ pet nurturing titles, to mature rated zombie shooters and everything in-between. Outside of video games, Ben is married, a proud father and loves motorcycles and other toys that are fast!

Published Oct. 7th 2013
  • xuankienkt_9659
    Understanding Profit, Flight Cost and Experience in Pocket Planes


    There are two common questions in Pocket Planes. 1) How much experience do I earn from a flight? 2) How is profit and flight cost determined?

    I answered the experience question in a previous post, which I’ll elaborate on more in the next few days. Today I will explain flight profit and cost, how it is calculated and how it all breaks down.

    Profit

    Profit = Revenue – Expense

    That’s pretty simple right? The profit you earn on a flight is a result of the total revenue from the flight, minus the total cost to get the aircraft to it’s final destination.

    So how is flight cost, i.e. expense from the equation above, calculated?

    READ ALL : https://onclan.com/tip/understanding-profit-flight-cost-and-experience-in-pocket-planes.Y4A1LN9lr1qj84RA
  • xuankienkt
    Pocket Planes Cheats And Tips
    Whether you're a Pocket Planes addict who's been unable to resist the lure of Nimble Bit's latest game, or you're completely new to their hellishly addictive brand of business sims, we've got all the tips, cheats and tricks you'll need to become the next Richard Branson.
    READ FULL : https://onclan.com/tip/pocket-planes-cheats-and-tips.Y49xa791GlPkT6BM
  • cheamo
    I don't see how spending more real money and having to wait more are good things at all to a user. Those are the things that make the vast majority of mobile games suck. You speak like Pocket Planes is worse because they didn't do as good a job exploiting their users.
  • jaxon pocket planes
    Fuck you u disgrace pocket planes is the BEAST FUCK POCKET TRAINS AND ILL SHOVE A LOAD TRAIN TRACKS UP UR ASS
  • helloworld_1087
    This is a pretty poor review for several reasons. Let's tackle them one at a time.

    Firstly, for some reason, you think it's a benefit to your readers that they are pushed to spend real money more so than in Pocket Planes, in order to progress at the rate they want. Who are you reviewing this for, gamers or developers? You use this several times, even as a main point. I'm all for giving indie developers like Nimblebit what they deserve, but you shouldn't even try to count this as a reason to prefer the game.

    Secondly, in Pocket Planes, while you can buy planes outright, they cost significantly more Bux to do so, and so the balance there is between speed and cost, much like the trains you so love for this quality. Apparently you didn't realise that 'this layer of complexity over a simple set of actions' existed.

    Thirdly, your graphs are pretty questionable data to say the least given that Pocket Planes actually peaked higher, something you highlight.

    Fourthly, you say the delays in refueling are good to get you away from the monotony of repetitive tasks. If you find the game 'repetitive or shallow', just stop playing it. Don't spin it as one for the plus column.

    And finally, you seem to have missed the fact that one of the better aspects of this game is the fact that route planning is difficult, not simplistic. You are only allowed one train per route, so it actual becomes an exercise in logistics with significant planning involved. If you think Pocket Planes was harder to plan (good) routes, you're clearly not doing it right.

    Judging from your love of simplicity, and spending money on fake currency, I suggest you stick to Farmville. It seems more your cup of tea.
  • TartarusMkII
    I think that you contradict yourself a lot in your article. You want the game to be simple but complex, and say it's bad that a game be too simple, or too complex (for mobile).

Cached - article_comments_article_9010
Related