Image Credit: Bethesda
Forgot password
Enter the email address you used when you joined and we'll send you instructions to reset your password.
If you used Apple or Google to create your account, this process will create a password for your existing account.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
Reset password instructions sent. If you have an account with us, you will receive an email within a few minutes.
Something went wrong. Try again or contact support if the problem persists.
MLB The Show 24 cards showing best players
Image via SIE San Diego Studio

Best Player Ratings for Every Team in MLB The Show 24

Find out who the best players are before you dive into the game!

Ratings, ratings, ratings. Every sports game has them, and every sports game player wants to know who’s the best in the upcoming season. MLB The Show 24 belongs to this group, and as soon as the game was released, there were questions online looking for a list of the best players. Well, look no further, as we’re bringing in the best player ratings for every team in MLB The Show 24!

Recommended Videos

Best Players List in MLB The Show 24

MLB The Show 24 player singaling to the audience
Image by SIE San Diego Studio

Check out our full list of the best players on every team in the table below. We will show the players with the overall best rating in their team. If you see two players shown for one team, it means they have the same rating and share the first place for that team.

TeamPlayer / Rating
Arizona DiamondbacksZac Gallen (P)
Rating: 91
Corbin Carrol (OF)
Rating: 91
Atlanta BeaversRonald Acuna Jr. (OF)
Rating: 99
Baltimore OriolesAdley Rutschman (C)
Rating: 91
Boston Red SoxRafael Devers (IN)
Rating: 87
Chicago CubsCody Bellinger (OF)
Rating: 88
Chicago White SoxLuis Robert Jr. (OF)
Rating: 89
Cincinnati RedsMatt McLain (IN)
Rating: 84
Cleaveland GuardiansJose Ramirez (IN)
Rating: 90
Colorado RockiesNolan Jones (OF)
Rating: 88
Detroit TigersTarik Skubal (P)
Rating: 86
Houston AstrosYordan Alvarez (OF)
Rating: 96
Kansas City RoyalsBobby Witt Jr. (IN)
Rating: 92
Los Angeles RoyalsMike Trout (OF)
Rating: 99
Los Angeles DodgersMookie Betts (OF)
Rating: 99
Shohei Ohtani (P/DH)
Rating: 99
Miami MarlinsTanner Scott (P)
Rating: 91
Milwaukee BrewersWilliam Contreras (C)
Rating: 86
Minnesota Twins Pablo Lopez (P)
Rating: 88
New York MetsFrancisco Lindor (IN)
Rating: 92
New York YankeesAaron Judge (OF)
Rating: 99
Oakland AthleticsZack Gelof (IN)
Rating: 78
Brent Rooker (OF)
Rating: 78
Philadelphia Phillies Zack Wheeler (P)
Rating: 93
Pittsburgh PiratesDavid Bednar (P)
Rating: 92
San Diego PadresFernando Tatis Jr. (OF)
Rating: 92
San Francisco Giants Logan Webb (P)
Rating: 88
Seattle MarinersPaul Goldschmidt (IN)
Rating: 91
St. Louis CardinalsPaul Goldschmitt (IN)
Rating: 91
Tampa Bay RaysPete Fairbanks (P)
Rating: 88
Texas RangersCorey Seager (IN)
Rating: 98
Toronto Blue JaysKevin Gausman (P)
Rating: 90
Vladimir Guerrero Jr. (IN)
Rating: 90
Washington NationalsLane Thomas (OF)
Rating: 83

And there you have it! A complete list of all the best players on each team for MLB The Show 24! Check out more guides for the game in our MLB The Show 24 guide hub.

GameSkinny is supported by our audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn a small affiliate commission. Learn more about our Affiliate Policy
Image of Djordje Ivanovic
Djordje Ivanovic
Đorđe Ivanović (Djordje Ivanovic) is a writer that has been with GameSkinny from 2024. He has a BA in Journalism and five years of professional writing experience behind him, with a recent personal focus on gaming and technology niches. His interests include WWII games, puzzle games, Path of Exile, Overwatch and other live service games. In his free time, you will find this adamant fan of Dota solving some sort of escape room games, and getting familiar with board gaming.